Executive Team Effectiveness Toolkit

Practical tools for improving the effectiveness of nonprofit executive teams

Welcome to Bridgespan’s Executive Team Effectiveness Toolkit for nonprofit organizations! Through our research and experience working with nonprofits for nearly 20 years, we have distilled a sequence of five steps, framed as questions, that have helped many executive teams increase their overall effectiveness and move from good to great.

Is the CEO effectively managing the executive team?

Is the executive team focused on the most important work?

Does executive team composition support its ability to do the work?

Do meeting and communications processes support superior decisions and execution?

Does the team's dynamic foster the right conversations and results?

  • Take the Diagnostic
  • Use the Online Toolkit
  • Download the PDF Toolkit
  • Why Use This Toolkit?

    The purpose of this toolkit is to help you and your nonprofit executive team improve your effectiveness in one or more of these five areas. To get started, we recommend you and your team start by reading this article on executive team effectiveness and taking our 5-10 minute diagnostic survey on executive team effectiveness. To increase your team's effectiveness, it’s important to know which areas your team is strong in—and which areas need improvement. The effective executive team diagnostic helps teams explore this and pinpoint those key areas that will help them move from good to great in their work together. Use the results to determine where to start, or jump in to the toolkit below.

    Take the Executive Team Effectiveness Diagnostic


    Action plan template

    After you've taken the diagnostic, the Executive Team Effectiveness Action Plan template can help you and your team plan and document what you'll improve on over the next year.

    What Each Section Contains

    The Executive Team Effectiveness Toolkit is broken into the following sections.

    Each sections includes:

    Introductory information about the challenges to address in each area

    An easy-to-use tool to improve the effectiveness of your nonprofit executive team for each area:

    • CEO checklist for leading executive teams
    • An interdependence/stakes matrix that helps identify the work of the executive team
    • Executive team composition questions
    • Meeting agenda template
    • Effective executive team behaviors examples

    Process steps for how to use the recommended tool (where applicable)

    An example of a tool-in-action from another nonprofit executive team (where applicable)

    Peer perspectives from other nonprofit leaders with advice related to the overall topic and/or how they have used a specific tool

    You can choose to walk through the entire toolkit below or jump into it by section using the above links.

    Toolkit cover

    Download the Executive Team Effectiveness Toolkit

    You can download a PDF of the entire toolkit by clicking the button below. The 34-page PDF contains each of these steps in an easy-to-use format that can be shared and discussed with your nonprofit's executive team members. The button below will take you to a form to fill out to receive the download. 

    Download the Executive Team Effectiveness Toolkit

    CEO Management of the Executive Team

    CEO Management of the Executive Team

    The executive team is the charge of the CEO. As head the head of the nonprofit organization, CEOs are accountable for results and responsible for determining what the executive team must do to achieve those results. Specifically, CEOs set expectations and define the executive team's work, steer meeting agendas, and support team members to grow while holding them accountable for performance. CEOs also maintain ultimate decision-making authority over what the team focuses on and how they do their work, while fostering strong relationships with team members.

    Besides being clear on the CEO’s role, determining whether an executive team is even needed is important. Not all organizations need a group of senior leaders to come together to collaborate on leading the nonprofit organization. It is the responsibility of the CEO to determine whether or not an executive team is needed, and, if it is, to form the team that is best suited to the organization’s needs.

    Download a PDF of this section

    The following considerations could indicate that your organization would benefit from an executive team:

    Is an executive team needed?

    Executive team need flowchart

    If you’ve said “yes” to these considerations, then you may be ready for an executive team.

    Tools for Managing Executive Teams

    CEO Checklist for Managing Executive Teams

    In our research, every high-performing team we identified was led by a CEO who intentionally managed the team. This checklist highlights a number of steps nonprofit CEOs can take to more effectively lead their executive teams. Use it to assess your approach to executive team management and where it might need improvement.

    Download the CEO Checklist for Managing Executive Teams | PDF >>

    CEO checklist

    It’s important for any nonprofit CEO to maximize executive team effectiveness in service of the organization’s impact. Yet, inspiring high performance of the executive team isn’t easy. We spoke to three CEOs, Kirstin Chernawsky of Erie Neighborhood House, Eric Robbins of the Jewish Federation of Greater Atlanta, and Dorri McWhorter of YWCA Metropolitan Chicago, to learn how they approach leading their teams and which efforts have been particularly powerful.

    Speech bubbles icon

    How to Lead High-Performing Nonprofit Executive Teams
    Roxane White, former CEO and president of Nurse-Family Partnership, shares approaches used to encourage nonprofit executive team effectiveness.

    How to Integrate Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion into Everyday Operations
    This article by Maria Hernandez, practice leader for Global Consulting Solutions at InclusionINC, discusses the practices and behaviors that nonprofit leaders need to adopt in order to live into the commitment of integrating diversity, equity, and inclusion into their organizations. 

    When the Change Needs to Be You
    This column by leadership consultant Nicki Roth helps leaders assess their need to change and offers guidelines for changing leadership behavior. 

    Build It and They Will Lead
    The River Group, a leading consulting firm for for-profit executive teams talks about what CEOs must do to actively develop their executive team into a higher performing unit.

    Stack of books icon

    Work of the Executive Team

    Work of the Executive Team

    Getting clear about the most important things for the team to focus on—and just as important where it shouldn't spend its valuable time—is critical to determining who should participate and how the team should conduct its business. Clarity, however, eludes many teams. Only 19 percent of our survey respondents strongly agreed that their executive team focuses on the right work.

    Download a PDF of this section

    Typically, the right work involves guiding the nonprofit organization toward achieving its top priorities and ensuring cross-departmental decision making and resource allocation.

    Is the executive team focused on the most important work?

    Executive team focus points infographic

    Interdependent Issues: 
    Those involving multiple units or functions where cross-leader discussion is critical for effective decision making.
    High Stakes Issues: Those having the most impact on the organization’s strategic clarity and priorities, programmatic and organizational effectiveness, development of future leaders, external reputation, and financial sustainability. 

    Tools for Identifying the Work

    Tools for Identifying the Work

    The Interdependence/Stakes Matrix helps nonprofit executive teams determine their priority activities and decisions. The tool (available as PDF and PowerPoint by clicking below) and step-by-step instructions will help you apply it to your executive team’s work.

    Interdependence Stakes Matrix

    Without clarity around the work they must do, many executive teams fall into a cycle of unproductive meetings and feelings of dissatisfaction with the impact they’re having on their organizations. One tool, the interdependence/stakes matrix, can help teams avoid these. Here several CEOs and a chief of staff describe how they’ve used the tool and how it’s benefited the work of their executive teams.

    Chat bubbles icon

    How to Define the Work of Nonprofit Executive Teams
    This Q&A with leadership expert Ruth Wageman looks at how to get teams focused on the priorities that will make the most of their valuable time.

    Good Plow, Wrong Field
    Leading consulting firm to for-profit executive teams, The River Group, shares how CEOs can ensure their executive teams are focused on the right work at the right level.

    Stack of books icon

    Executive Team Composition

    Executive Team Composition

    Finding the right combination of perspectives and competencies to fill an executive team is critical. At first, CEOs might be inclined to build a team composed of their direct reports, yet doing so could limit the diverse perspective needed for the work. Executive team members need to take a big-picture perspective and have business acumen, and non-direct reports may possess unique skills essential to the team's work. Diversity among executive team members also is another critical consideration.

    Download a PDF of this section

    Including all the right perspectives can sometimes be at odds with keeping the team a manageable size. In fact, many nonprofit executive teams are too big. CEOs who rate their teams as highly effective balance two critical questions:

    Critical questions infographic

    Finding this balance may not result in a group composed of the CEO’s direct reports, e.g.

    • You may want fewer members if the CEO has a large number of direct reports.
    • You may want to augment the team with other members if certain critical perspectives are missing.

    Tools for Determining Executive Team Composition

    Key Questions to Ask About Executive Team Composition

    This one-pager walks you through three areas—optimizing team composition, considering two top teams, and evolving team composition—to help you assess where you have the right people on your team.

    Download Key Questions About Executive Team Composition | PDF >>

    Key questions

    Executive Team Composition: Peer Perspectives

    Most nonprofit executive teams we’ve worked with have between four and six members. However, some CEOs prefer larger teams as a means to ensure the right perspectives are brought to bear for critical decisions. Other CEOs opt to balance the trade-offs inherent with larger teams and decision-making complexity and the desire for more perspectives by creating both a smaller executive team and a larger management team. The nonprofit leaders interviewed here share how they approached forming their executive teams

    Speech bubbles icon

    Additional Resources

    How Managers Become Leaders
    Harvard Business Review author Michael Watkins, professor of Leadership and Organizational Change at IMD, discusses the required perspectives and capabilities for executive team effectiveness.

    The Ballooning Executive Team
    Harvard Business Review article by Jacques Neatby, an advisor to North American and European executive teams, shares how CEOs can address oversized executive teams.

    How to Optimize Nonprofit Executive Team Composition
    This Bridgespan Q&A with leadership consultant Nicki Roth takes a look at how CEOs can assess what they need to lead their organizations over the long haul; it provides a good starting point from which to consider who and what roles should be on the executive team.

    Stack of books icon

    Effective Executive Team Meetings

    Effective Executive Team Meetings

    Well-managed meeting and internal communications processes are essential for a successful nonprofit executive team. They require establishing the right practices, right amount time and location, and, often, pre-reads to prepare everyone for productive discussions. You can improve your meeting effectiveness through the following four steps, beginning with proactive preparation, and the downloadable tools found below.

    Download a PDF of this section

    Effective meetings infographic

    Tools for Effective Executive Team Meetings

    Executive Team Meetings Agenda Templates

    A well-planned agenda can go a long way to helping a meeting stay on track and achieve its purpose. This template can help you build an agenda for your next executive team meeting.

    Download meeting agenda templates, instructions & examples:
    Agenda template, instructions & examples | PDF>>
    Meeting Agenda template | Excel >>
    Meeting Agenda template | Word >>
    Meeting Agenda example (KidsNGO) | PDF >>
    Meeting Agenda example (Erie Neighborhood House) | Word >>

    Download meeting wrap-up and updates templates:
    Meeting Wrap-up template | PPT >>
    Meeting Wrap-up example | PDF >>
    Written Updates template | PPT >>

    Team meeting agenda template

    Effective Executive Team Meetings: Peer Perspectives

    If your executive team suffers from unproductive meetings, it could be that you don’t have a good agenda setting process. Many executive teams have used the agenda template tool presented in this toolkit to help them achieve more effective meetings and communication processes. Here a number of nonprofit leaders share their approaches to making their meetings and communications more effective.

    Speech bubbles icon

    Additional Resources

    Death by Meeting and Death by Meeting digital materials
    Noted author and speaker on team effectiveness Pat Lencioni shares his approach to meetings, including activities and templates to guide implementation.

    Making Every Meeting Matter
    Harvard Business Review
    guide provides a variety of perspectives on making any meeting more effective. 

    The Meeting Advantage
    This web-based tool developed by The Table Group, Pat Lencioni’s consulting firm, offers information on cultivating organizational health through strong meetings; subscription required.

    How to Lead Effective Nonprofit Executive Team Meetings
    This short article by a Bridgespan Partner Libbie Landles-Cobb identifies common mistakes and good practices to transform nonprofit executive team meetings from time sinks into engaging opportunities to really get things done.

    Stack of books icon

    Executive Team Dynamics and Behaviors

    Executive Team Dynamics and Behaviors

    Organizational success requires a cohesive executive team. A cohesive team sets the tone for the rest of the organization, modeling the importance of collaborative behavior. Yet despite its importance, many teams underinvest in developing a productive working dynamic tailored to their specific work. The set of dynamics below can help get you started. They support productive engagement for an executive team.

    Download a PDF of this section

    The six key dynamics for executive teams

    Six key dynamics infographic

    Tools for Executive Team Dynamics and Behaviors

    Executive Team Dynamics and Behaviors: Peer Perspectives

    No two executive teams are alike when it comes to team dynamics and behaviors. Each team comprises a set of unique individuals, all of whom have their own approaches to work and personalities. Yet the effectiveness of the team relies on collaboration and alignment. One key lever a CEO can pull to ensure time together is well spent is to establish clear behavioral norms of how the team will work together.

    Speech bubbles icon

    Additional Resources

    Decision making

    Five Ways that Nonprofits Can Make Decision Making More Inclusive—and More Effective
    This article, based on The Bridgespan Group’s work with scores of local, national, and global nonprofits and NGOs around decision making, looks at five promising approaches for making decisions in ways that are both inclusive and effective, leading to more equitable outcomes.

    Structuring Leadership: Alternative Models for Distributing Power and Decision-Making in Nonprofit Organizations
    This article from the Building Movement Project highlights distributed leadership structures, including elements and practices that must be in place for alternative models to work and common indicators of success.


    Team dynamics

    Building a Better Executive Team
    The River Group shares the indicators of success for an effective executive team, particularly around assessing the quality of team dialogue.

    High-Performing Teams Need Psychological Safety. Here’s How to Create It
    Author Laura Delizonna, executive coach and Stanford University instructor, discusses the importance of trust for high-performing teams and how teams can increase their level of psychological safety in this Harvard Business Review article.

    How to Support Effective Dynamics in Nonprofit Executive Teams
    Peter Thies, president of Boston-based consultancy The River Group, offers a glimpse inside his playbook for developing effective nonprofit executive teams, highlighting the team dynamics that support collaboration.

    Personal Histories Exercise
    Developed by the Table Group, this exercise helps improve trust by giving team members an opportunity to demonstrate vulnerability in a low-risk way and to help team members understand one another at a fundamental level so that they can avoid making false attributions about behaviors and intentions.

    Team Effectiveness Exercise
    Another exercise from the Table Group, this team effectiveness exercise gives team members a forum for providing one another with focused, direct, actionable feedback about how their individual behavior can improve the performance of the team. 

    Stack of books icon

    Peer Perspectives

    The nonprofit leaders featured in the Peer Perspectives here share how they've used this toolkit to build effective nonprofit executive teams. Short descriptions of these leaders and their organizations appear below. To read the individual articles for each of the five areas, please click on the links below. 

    Speech bubbles icon

    Nonprofit Organizations Featured in This Toolkit

    Kirstin Chernawsky

    Kirstin Chernawsky, Executive Director, Erie Neighborhood House
    Based in Chicago, Erie Neighborhood House provides programs for Latinx immigrants alongside individuals and families of all backgrounds focused on education, critical services, and trauma-informed care. They have around 200 employees and an annual budget of around $9 million.

    Dorri McWhorter

    Dorri McWhorter, CEO, YWCA Metropolitan Chicago
    The YWCA Metropolitan Chicago provides comprehensive services to women and families spanning economic empowerment, health and wellness, STEAM and youth programming, early childhood education, family support, and sexual violence support services. It also provides workplace solutions to advance diversity, equity, and inclusion. It has nearly 200 employees and a $24 million an annual budget.

    Eric Robbins

    Eric Robbins, President/CEO, Jewish Federation of Greater Atlanta (JFGA)
    JFGA cares for, connects and strengthens the Jewish community throughout greater Atlanta, Israel, and the world. Federation has a professional staff of around 75 and an annual budget of $11 million.

    Healthcare icon

    Featured Healthcare Organization
    This healthcare organization provides medical services in Illinois. They have around 300 employees. 

    Additional Executive Team Resources

    All of the resources shared in this toolkit can be found in this article. The list includes resources written by Bridgespan authors as well as external experts in nonprofit leadership and management. Bookmark the list to have quick access to answers to your questions about effective nonprofit executive teams. 

    Stack of books icon